In a shock for both the Irish and European political establishment, the European Union’s Lisbon Treaty has been defeated in Thursday’s 26-County referendum.
The final results have shown the treaty was rejected by 53.4% to 46.6%. Turnout was a high 53.1%, at the highest levels of similar European referenda in Ireland.
Justice Minister Dermot Ahern conceded the vote shortly after midday on Friday as tallies came in from around the country showed the treaty had been defeated in an overwhelming number of constituencies.
Political leaders and the international media were present when the result was confirmed by election officials in Dublin Castle this evening. There were jubilant scenes among young ‘No’ campaigners, who chanted, sang and waved banners as the result was read out.
Ireland ranks in surveys as one of the EU’s most pro-European states, and ‘No’ campaigners have been keen to point out that the vote is not a rejection of the Union.
However, they pointed to the anti-democratic nature of the the treaty, which was was itself an effort to resurrect an EU constitution which was rejected in referenda by French and Dutch voters in 2005.
The treaty had the backing of the three main political parties in Ireland, which has prospered under EU membership. Farmers groups, businesses, churches, labour unions and the mainstream media also backed it.
However, in the end, support was mainly limited to Dublin’s wealthy suburbs. The east of the country was closely divided, while the west, south and north were clearly against the treaty.
Europea n bureaucrats were struggling today to come to terms with the result. The need for both the Treaty and the direction of the European project to be re-evaluated had clearly not been taken on board by international political leaders who commented this afternoon.
“Ireland will for sure find a way to ratify this treaty,” Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk told reporters. French officials insisted work on the treaty would continue, while the British government has said their plans to ratify the treaty would go on regardless.
However, the Labour Party leader Eamon Gilmore, who backed the treaty, accepted it was now “dead” and there was no possibility of a re-run. Such was the outcome for the Nice Treaty of 2001, which passed almost unchanged in a second referendum after initially being rejected. The high turnout on Thursday, and the major public debate which took place in the latter weeks of the campaign, indicate a profound problem for Lisbon Treaty supporters.
Sinn Fein’s Mary Lou McDonald said it would be impossible for Irish leaders to wriggle out of the referendum result.
“This is a moment of democratic truth here. Do you listen to the people or don’t you?”
She said that the Taoiseach Brian Cowen would have to get the treaty negotiated.
FINAL RESULTS (View using fixed font)
Constituency Electorate Turnout Yes No Carlow-Kilkenny 103,397 52,644 (50.9%) 26,210 (50.0%) 26,206 (50.0%) Cavan-Monaghan 92,920 49,649 (53.4%) 22,346 (45.2%) 27,113 (54.8%) Clare 77,398 40,617 (52.5%) 20,982 (51.8%) 19,490 (48.2%) Cork East 83,850 42,398 (50.6%) 18,177 (43.0%) 24,052 (57.0%) Cork North Central 65,738 35,120 (53.4%) 12,440 (35.6%) 22,546 (64.4%) Cork North West 63,574 35,358 (55.6%) 16,253 (46.1%) 18,991 (53.9%) Cork South Central 89,844 49,455 (55.0%) 22,112 (44.9%) 27,166 (55.1%) Cork South West 58,225 32,184 (55.3%) 14,235 (44.4%) 17,806 (55.6%) Donegal-North East 56,195 25,654 (45.7%) 9,006 (35.3%) 16,504 (64.7%) Donegal-South West 60,079 27,946 (46.5%) 10,174 (36.6%) 17,659 (63.4%) Dublin Central 57,864 28,265 (48.8%) 12,328 (43.8%) 15,816 (56.2%) Dublin Mid-West 61,622 31,833 (51.7%) 12,577 (39.6%) 19,182 (60.4%) Dublin North 81,550 45,077 (55.3%) 22,696 (50.6%) 22,194 (49.4%) Dublin North-Central 51,156 31,245 (61.1%) 15,772 (50.6%) 15,396 (49.4%) Dublin North-East 52,432 29,991 (57.2%) 12,917 (43.2%) 16,973 (56.8%) Dublin North-West 49,893 26,394 (52.9%) 9,576 (36.4%) 16,749 (63.6%) Dublin South 87,855 51,342 (58.4%) 32,190 (62.9%) 19,005 (37.1%) Dublin South West 67,499 36,181 (53.6%) 12,601 (34.9%) 23,456 (65.1%) Dublin South-Central 81,743 42,170 (51.6%) 16,410 (39.0%) 25,624 (61.0%) Dublin South-East 56,202 27,871 (49.6%) 17,111 (61.7%) 10,644 (38.3%) Dublin West 52,173 28,421 (54.5%) 13,573 (47.9%) 14,754 (52.1%) Dun Laoghaire 84,710 49,810 (58.8%) 31,524 (63.5%) 18,149 (36.5%) Galway East 80,569 40,124 (49.8%) 18,728 (46.9%) 21,230 (53.1%) Galway West 85,642 42,844 (50.0%) 19,643 (46.1%) 23,011 (53.9%) Kerry North 54,787 28,120 (51.3%) 11,306 (40.4%) 16,702 (59.6%) Kerry South 51,338 27,257 (53.1%) 11,569 (42.6%) 15,571 (57.4%) Kildare North 71,429 36,815 (51.5%) 20,045 (54.6%) 16,653 (45.4%) Kildare South 57,145 27,858 (48.7%) 13,470 (48.5%) 14,308 (51.5%) Laois-Offaly 105,053 56,992 (54.3%) 31,786 (56.0%) 24,963 (44.0%) Limerick East 76,735 39,444 (51.4%) 18,085 (46.0%) 21,191 (54.0%) Limerick West 57,847 29,958 (51.8%) 13,318 (44.6%) 16,511 (55.4%) Longford-West Meath 81,834 42,065 (51.4%) 19,371 (46.3%) 22,502 (53.7%) Louth 83,458 44,565 (53.4%) 18,586 (41.9%) 25,811 (58.1%) Mayo 95,250 48,822 (51.3%) 18,624 (38.3%) 30,001 (61.7%) Meath East 67,415 34,148 (50.7%) 17,340 (50.9%) 16,703 (49.1%) Meath West 62,816 32,589 (51.9%) 14,442 (44.5%) 18,028 (55.5%) Roscommon-South Leitrim 59,728 33,962 (56.9%) 15,429 (45.6%) 18,402 (54.4%) Sligo-North Leitrim 55,591 29,228 (52.6%) 12,602 (43.3%) 16,496 (56.7%) Tipperary North 55,941 32,750 (58.5%) 16,235 (49.8%) 16,367 (50.2%) Tipperary South 53,687 29,756 (55.4%) 13,853 (46.8%) 15,755 (53.2%) Waterford 72,052 38,474 (53.4%) 17,502 (45.7%) 20,812 (54.3%) Wexford 101,124 53,369 (52.8%) 23,371 (44.0%) 29,793 (56.0%) Wicklow 85,918 52,272 (60.8%) 25,936 (49.8%) 26,130 (50.2%) Total 3,051,278 1,621,037 (53.1%) 752,451 (46.6%) 862,415 (53.4%)