Sinn Féin critique of IMC
Sinn Féin critique of IMC
The following is Sinn Féin’s case against the Independent Monitoring Commission (sanctions body) according to a statement from the party today.


  • The IMC is not part of the Agreement

  • It relies on reports from securocrats and security services/PSNI, hence is not independent, a smokescreen for political intervention on basis of securocrat agenda.

  • Its membership includes - John Alderdice, a political opponent of SF for the past 30 years, John Grieve, former head of the Metropolitan Police and officer in charge of the operation in which unarmed IRA volunteer Diarmuid O,Neill who, while trying to surrender, was shot dead by police, and Joe Brosnan, former Secretary General of the Department of Justice in Dublin, and Richard Kerr, former Deputy Director of the CIA

  • The IMC recommends sanctions against Sinn Féin, yet offers not even one allegation that Sinn Féin is in any way in breach of the Agreement, nor does it suggest Sinn Féin are.

  • The IMC recognises that Sinn Féin is not the IRA, that SF is not in a position to determine what the IRA may do, that Sinn Féin has used its influence well.

  • The IMC report is clearly absurd and contradictory and its conclusions are politically driven.

  • Sinn Féin is not in breach of the Agreement. In fact we have used our influence to good effect throughout this process.

  • And of course Sinn Féin will not be held responsible for any words or deeds other than our own.

  • The irony is that the most glaring breach of the Agreement and one which is continuing is the suspension of the political institutions by the British Government.

  • Continuing suspension allows unionists who otherwise would be exposed as refusing to take part in the institutions off the hook.

  • The IMC’s report disgracefully reduces the ongoing unionist paramilitary campaign of bombing and murder to a postscript with reference to murders by loyalists such as the killing of James McMahon or Andrew Cully lumped together in a single sentence. And, of course the report exonerated the two governments entirely.

  • It is noticeable that the report failed to mention the DUP,s links with Ulster Resistance or to draw attention to the fact that the bulk of the guns imported by British Agent Brian Nelson remain in the hands of unionist paramilitaries.

  • Nor does the report draw attention to the UUP membership of the Loyalist Commission, at a time when the unionist paramilitary organisations on this Commission were carrying out murders and other attacks on Catholics and nationalists, that the UUP remain on the Commission, or that the UUP is linked to the Orange Order who annually visit violence on sections of the Catholic community during their marching season.

  • Sinn Féin is happy to engage in a debate on who is in breach of the Agreement, in fact we have asked for this in the Review.

  • The Good Friday Agreement deals with the issue of sanctions, and that we fully support. The so-called sanctions mechanism and the powers accrued to the British Secretary of State as a result of the legislation which accompanied the establishment of the IMC are a breach of the Agreement ^ in fact they contravene the safeguards built into the Agreement and its provisions for democratic accountability.

  • This financial penalty will undermine the capacity of Sinn Féin to fulfil their duties as MLAs

  • We demand for our electorate the same democratic rights, entitlements and treatment as all other sections of the electorate.

  • The Sinn Féin mandate must therefore be respected.

  • Urgent Appeal

    Despite increasing support for Irish freedom and unity, we need your help to overcome British and unionist intransigence. We can end the denial of our rights in relation to Brexit, the Irish language, a border poll and legacy issues, with your support.

    Please support IRN now to help us continue reporting and campaigning for our national rights. Even one pound a month can make a big difference for us.

    Your contribution can be made with a credit or debit card by clicking below. A continuing monthly donation of £2 or more will give you full access to this site. Thank you. Go raibh míle maith agat.

    © 2004 Irish Republican News